USCPR Executive Director Yousef Munayyer appeared on Democracy Now! to discuss Israelâs ânation-stateâ law constitutionally enshrining apartheid.
AMY GOODMAN: For more, weâre joined byÂ Democracy Now!Â video stream by Yousef Munayyer, the executive director of the US Campaign for Palestinian Rights. And joining us in studio, Rebecca Vilkomerson, executive director of Jewish Voice for Peace, co-authored a newÂ op-edÂ inÂ The IndependentÂ headlined âAs Jews, we reject the myth that itâs antisemitic to call Israel racist.â
We welcome you both toÂ Democracy Now!Â Yousef, letâs begin with you. If you can talk about whatâs happened in Gaza right now, the death toll up to 140, and then move on to the law that was just passed on Thursday?
YOUSEFÂ MUNAYYER:Â Sure. Well, the most recent events that weâve seen in the Gaza Strip are sort of a escalation that happens from time to time and forces, you know, many in the media and us here in the United States and the outside world to tune back in to Gaza, based on the fear that it is on the brink of yet another major Israeli bombardment. But the reality is that in those moments when we are not tuned in, the constant and structural violence that Palestinians in Gaza face because of the occupation, because of the policies of Israeli siege and because of the violent methods of enforcement that the Israeli military uses to support those policies, continues all the time.
And this is, altogether, part of a broader agenda by the state of Israel to quell any sort of resistance to what it seeks to do throughout the entirety of the territory, which is to impose its will on the native population of Palestinians, both in the West Bank, in Gaza, in occupied territories, but also on Palestinian citizens of Israel, under the premise that it is the Jewish population that is in control, that deserves to be in control, and that any rights at all that may be afforded to, you know, non-Jews are really done as a favor, and not something that the Jewish state has to do because of principles of equality or tolerance or democracy or anything like that.
And the most recent step that the Israeli Knesset has taken, through the passage of this law, I think, is the best proof of that, showing very clearly that the Israelis no longer care about, you know, even pretending to balance this notion of being a Jewish state and a democracy. You know, I think that was never the case. Now itâs clear that theyâre not even interested in pretending anymore. And, in fact, the initiator and sponsor of this legislation said, after its passage, âWe are passing this bill to make sure that no one has any doubt, or even any thoughts, about Israel being a state of all its citizens. So itâs very clearly aimed at enshrining inequality, enshrining apartheid, in a constitutional way within Israeli law.
AG: Rebecca Vilkomerson, if you can respond to this, whatâs being called the nation-state law thatâs been passed?
REBECCAÂ VILKOMERSON:Â Yeah. I mean, I think what Yousef said is exactly right. I think I found it shocking, but not surprising, because I think anytime you have a set of, again, foundational lawâthis is a basic law, so itâs sort of the equivalent of a constitutional bill that will then have an impact on any future laws. And it basically obligates the state to treat its non-Jewish citizens unequally. And thatâs 20 percent of the overall Israeli population. So, by Israel enshrining racism and discrimination and apartheid into its basic law, thatâs pretty shocking, at the same time not that surprising because of the ongoing policies that Israel has been pursuing for so many decades.
AG: And the response of the Jewish community?
RV:Â Well, here in the United States, I think itâs been interesting, because thereâs much more unanimity than there usually is against this billâyou know, everyone, from J Street to the American Jewish Committee to the Reform and Conservative movements, which together represent half of American Jewry. Even some right-wing organizations like theÂ ADLÂ have had some limited concerns about the bill. And I think itâs a reflection ofâyou know, Peter Beinart sort of had this seminal essay that he wrote in 2010, which talked about the ways that the Israeliâthe Jewish Israeli population was moving to the right, and the American Jewish population is staying sort of liberal and progressive, and thereâs a split thatâs happening. And I think weâre seeing the fruition of that, and people are just horrified by the sort of extreme-right-wing agenda that I think the Netanyahu government is feeling empowered by the Trump administration to enact fully.
AG: You wrote aÂ pieceÂ inÂ The Independent, signed byâwell, about how 40 Jewish groups from 15 different countries have signed this joint statementâ
AG: âcondemning attempts to stifle criticism with falseâ
AG: âaccusations, you say, of anti-Semitism.
RV: Right. This is a pretty historic moment. Again, we had 40 organizations from around the world, Jewish and Israeli organizations. And we felt like it was very important, because there are so many efforts right now, worldwide, lots of different specific strategies and tactics, but worldwide, trying to legislate definitions of anti-Semitism, that sometimes include chilling language, at the very minimum, and sometimes actually legislate that forms of anti-Zionism or certain critiques of Israel would be defined as anti-Semitic. And this has resulted in bank accounts being shut down in Germany and in the U.K., people being prosecuted in France. Here in the United States, thereâs something called the Anti-Semitism Awareness Act, which would make it potentially, you know, extremely difficult for people to speak out politically against Israeli human rights violations. So we felt it was very important to lend a Jewish voice against that and to say thatÂ BDSÂ is a legitimate tactic to be using in this particular moment. Thatâs Boycottâ
AG: And youâre talking about the Boycott, Divestmentâ
RV: Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions, yes.
AG: âand Sanctions movement. Yousef Munayyer, what happens from here, after this law is passed, and also in Gaza?
YM: Well, I think thereâs great concern for what may happen in Gaza in the coming months. Of course, as we know, in the major Israeli bombardments of Gaza in 2008, 2009, and in the fall of 2012, in the summer of 2014, all of them preceded Israeli elections by a matter of months. And we are, you know, expecting Israeli elections in 2019. And given the recent behavior of the ruling coalition, with the passage of all kinds of right-wing legislation aimed at rallying the support of its base, I would not be surprised if they were to attempt another sort of massive operation against the Palestinian population in Gaza ahead of elections once again. So thatâs something that I would definitely keep my eye on. But Iâ
AG: Yousef Munayyerâwe have to leave it there for nowâUS Campaign for Palestinian Rights, and Rebecca Vilkomerson, Jewish Voice for Peace.
Opinion/Analysis 07/23/18Â UNOCHA: Essential Services in Gaza on Verge of Collapsing